Skip to content
Rate This Wine
Pair my dinnerWine with steakWine with salmonWine with pizzaSee all: PairingsCabernet SauvignonPinot NoirSauvignon BlancSee all: WinesBest wine clubsCheapest wine clubsFor beginnersSee all: Wine clubsWine pairing finderParty wine calculatorRate this wineSee all: ToolsLearn

Plonk Wine Club vs MYSA Natural Wine

Plonk Wine Club★★★★★★★★★★ 3.8From $110 per shipment vs MYSA Natural Wine★★★★★★★★★★ 3.8From $84.95 per shipment

We may earn a commission from links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never changes our picks. How we make money.

Quick verdict

Plonk Wine Club edges it overall, winning 2 of 4 rating categories. MYSA Natural Wine is cheaper to start ($84.95 vs $110).

Choose Plonk Wine Club if…

You’re adventurous drinkers who want organic and natural-leaning wines. A small-team club focused on organic, biodynamic and low-intervention wines from small producers, with recipes and stories in every box.

See current offer
Choose MYSA Natural Wine if…

You’re natural-wine fans who want low-intervention, small-farm wines. A natural-wine club and shop with clubs for orange, red and mixed natural wines, plus clear notes on how each wine is made.

See current offer

Side by side

Plonk Wine ClubMYSA Natural Wine
Our rating3.8/53.8/5
Value3.6/53.4/5
Wine quality4.3/54.2/5
Choice & personalization3.4/53.5/5
Flexibility4/54.1/5
Starting price$110$84.95
Approx. per bottle$26$28
Bottles per shipment4, 6 or 123, 6 or 12 (4 in red and orange clubs)
How oftenMonthlyEvery 1, 2 or 3 months
ShippingIncludedVaries; check at checkout
Intro offer - -
GuaranteeSatisfaction guaranteeSatisfaction guarantee
Skip / cancelSkip or cancel onlineSkip or cancel online
What you can chooseMixed, red-only or white-only; organic and biodynamic focusNatural, orange, red and pét-nat wines
Ships toMany US statesMany US states
Best forAdventurous drinkers who want organic and natural-leaning winesNatural-wine fans who want low-intervention, small-farm wines

Plonk Wine Club: pros & cons

  • Thoughtful picks from small organic producers
  • Shipping included
  • Great recipe cards and producer notes
  • About $25+ a bottle
  • Fewer states than the big clubs
  • Styles can be funky for beginners

Read the full Plonk Wine Club review

MYSA Natural Wine: pros & cons

  • Real natural wines from small farms
  • Clear notes on farming and winemaking
  • Orange-wine and pét-nat options
  • Pricey per bottle
  • Natural styles aren’t for everyone
  • Limited personalization

Read the full MYSA Natural Wine review